Category Archives: Judicial Review

A Judicial Roll Call – Encompassing 3 Years of (mostly) Judicial Failure, re: My ChB 2nd Appeal

I thoroughly dissect, and heavily criticise Judge J. Verman’s STATEMENT OF REASONS, especially as some of her rationale is distinctly at odds with her reasoning in the 1st ChB Appeal, though it inexplicably finds in my Ex’s favour again.  Continue reading

Posted in 2nd Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, HMCTS, HMRC, Judge Kate Markus QC - Upper Tribunal, Judge Keith Wilding, Judge Miss J. R. Beale, Judge Mrs J. Verman, Judges, Judicial Review, Legal, Record of Proceedings, Royal Courts Of Justice, Slowly rotting, The Honourable Mrs Justice Lambert, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

A Judicial Roll Call – Encompassing 5 Years of (mostly) Judicial Failure, re: My ChB 1st Appeal

How on Earth can Judge Blackett say my claim doesn’t raise an important point of principle or practice, when for several years HMRC/Child Benefit Office (& the CSA) have consistently FAILED  to contact the family of my daughter’s then-boyfriend to establish the material living arrangements for the material period, by insisting they are prevented by law from contacting such a “third party”!!! Continue reading

Posted in 1st Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, HMCTS, HMRC, Judge G. I. Marsh, Judge Janet Ward, Judge Jeff Blackett - His Honour, Judge Miss R. L. Campbell, Judge Mrs J. Verman, Judge N. P. Sellar, Judge Nicholas Wikeley - Upper Tribunal, Judge S. D. Ennals, Judges, Judicial Review, Legal, Record of Proceedings, Royal Courts Of Justice, Slowly rotting, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

His Honour Judge Jeff Blackett Refuses Me Permission To Apply For Judicial Review (re: ChB 1st Appeal)

How, pray tell,  can a Child Benefit  Appeal progress from First Tier Tribunal to Upper Tribunal, then back to First Tier Tribunal, then up again to Upper Tribunal, and then up to the Royal Courts of Justice, and throughout all of this time HMRC, the CSA, and various Judges at HMCTS all refuse to contact my daughter’s then-boyfriend’s family to confirm the material living arrangements for the material period, or to issue the reasonable Directions I’d requested? Continue reading

Posted in 1st Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, Child Support Agency, DWP, Fraud, HMCTS, HMRC, Judge G. I. Marsh, Judge Jeff Blackett - His Honour, Judge Mrs J. Verman, Judge Nicholas Wikeley - Upper Tribunal, Judge S. D. Ennals, Judges, Judicial Review, Legal, Royal Courts Of Justice, Slowly rotting, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

My Claim For A Judicial Review Has Been Issued (re: Child Benefit 2nd Claim)

The Royal Courts of Justice have issued my claim for a Judicial Review, for my 2nd ChB claim.  [I’ll write more when I have chance…..]

Posted in 2nd Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, HMCTS, HMRC, Judge Mrs J. Verman, Judges, Judicial Review, Legal, Royal Courts Of Justice, Slowly rotting, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , ,

Wednesday 15th November 2017 – Royal Courts of Justice Return a “Certificate of Service” That I’d Sent Them Last Week! (re: JR ChB 1st)

 I lamented that this wasn’t specified on the form, and I confirmed that the Royal Courts of Justice had received all 3 x Certificates of Service N215 on 10/11/17, (separately).  Continue reading

Posted in 1st Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, Complaint, HMCTS, HMRC, Judicial Review, Legal, Royal Courts Of Justice, Royal Mail, Slowly rotting, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday 14th November 2017 – I Post My Application For Judicial Review of Child Benefit (2nd Claim/Appeal) to Royal Courts of Justice

Tribunal Judge Beale refused my request to obtain my daughter’s mobile phone tracking data, which would have proved that my daughter went nowhere near her father’s house for several weeks. It isn’t mentioned in the Decision Notice of 18/10/16, but it is mentioned in the Record of Proceedings for that date, though not everything is legible. Continue reading

Posted in 1st Child Benefit Appeal, 2nd Child Benefit Appeal, BarProBono, Child Benefit, HMCTS, HMRC, Judge G. I. Marsh, Judge Kate Markus QC - Upper Tribunal, Judge Keith Wilding, Judge Miss J. R. Beale, Judge Mrs J. Verman, Judges, Judicial Review, Legal, Record of Proceedings, Royal Courts Of Justice, Royal Mail, Slowly rotting, The Honourable Mrs Justice Lambert, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

My Claim For A Judicial Review Has Been Issued (re: Child Benefit 1st Claim)

I woke up, early as usual.  Ablutions, then donned a fresh pair of pyjamas for today.   Continue reading

Posted in 1st Child Benefit Appeal, 2nd Child Benefit Appeal, Child Benefit, HMCTS, HMRC, Judicial Review, Legal, Royal Courts Of Justice, Royal Mail, Slowly rotting, The Upper Tribunal Office (Administrative Appeals Chamber), Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , ,